On October 9, The Daily Show featured an interview with Republican strategist Noelle Nikpour who argued that Obamacare is really unconstitutional except for the fact that the Supreme Court has declared it constitutional.
That Ms. Nikpour could regard the Affordable Care Act (i.e., Obamacare) constitutional and unconstitutional at the same time may seem irrational, but perhaps if we can understand this pattern of thinking – a pattern that seems to embody two parallel and incompatible universes - it may throw light not just Ms. Nikpour's mentality, but on the right wing of the GOP in general.
For example, conservative Republicans have described Obamacare as BOTH an unprecedented disaster that threatens to lead us into a Nazi-like slave society AND as something voters will like so much that they will never want to see it repealed.
Two parallel, yet contradictory, universes.
In one universe - let’s call it “the Real World” - Supreme Court decisions routinely render laws constitutional, and popular programs like Social Security and Medicare tend to improve people’s lives.
But, in “the Anti-Cosmos,” the parallel universe where Ms. Nikpour spends much of her time, the Supreme Court needs to butt out of constitutionality issues. And in the Anti-Cosmos, giving people access to affordable health care is equivalent to dragging them into hellish concentration camps.
A fascinating study by Democracy Corps, based on interviews with members of the Republican Party, helps explain why so many in that party seem to hold on to impossibly contradictory ideas. The study reveals that Republicans, when asked what words they associate with Barack Obama, overwhelmingly replied, “Liar.” The following were also prominently mentioned: Lies, Lie, Crook, Worst, Overrated, Liberal, and President.
“Communist/socialist” and “hypocrite” also made the list.
Naturally, if Republicans automatically assume that President Obama is a lying, liberal, socialist crook, they need not pay any attention to what he says. I’m guessing that other prominent Democrats, like Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi, get no more of a hearing from these people than Obama does.
So, when the president says he’s concerned about millions of Americans lacking insurance and he therefore wants to help them with his Affordable Care Act, non-Republicans may say, “Great, let’s do it.” But right-wing Republicans are more likely to disregard the president's rationale and say, “What is that lying crook up to now? He probably wants to take away our guns and mind-control us with electronic implants.” And nothing that Obama or any other Democrat can say will alter their thinking, because dark, distrustful ideas dominate the Anti-Cosmos where they spend much of their lives.
We should note that since 9-11 our government has set up a vast security system that is gathering oceans of data about us, much of it without our knowledge or approval, and this does not help Obama where issues of trust are concerned. Of course, this surveillance is not merely an Obama undertaking, but for people who start from the premise that he’s a lying socialist bent on enslaving us, blaming him for it just feels right.
It turns out that many conservative Republicans distrust the American public education system almost as much as they distrust Democrats. They also reject some of the findings of science. As the report says, “Evangelicals and Tea Party Republicans [the two main conservative GOP factions -- editor's note] share and are consumed by skepticism about climate science—to the point where they mistrust scientists before they begin to speak.”
So, if scientists talk about evidence that human activities are causing global warming, right-wing Republicans can simply disregard this input. The scientists, they believe, are part of the Obama conspiracy.
Who do the right-wing Republicans trust? Fox News, for one. Astonishingly, many of them do not regard Fox as conservative, but see it as a middle-of-the-road news source. According to one respondent, it’s the only network “in the middle.” Another claimed that it is about the only source that gives you both sides. [Holy Shit!! – editor’s note]
The survey distinguishes between the motivations of the Evangelicals and the Tea Party conservatives. The former believe that their world, which is white, traditional and Christian, is under assault and losing ground. They do not accept gay marriage or abortion rights and don’t want to offer undocumented aliens a path to citizenship.
Tea Party Republicans, on the other hand, don’t care so much about abortion or gay marriage. For them, Obama’s ultimate scheme is to make government so big that our freedom will be lost forever. Oddly, though they see government as the Evil Enemy of Freedom, they regard the Constitution, the very document that breathes life into government, as Sacred and Good. I think they must have a Real World understanding of the Constitution and an Anti-Cosmos attitude toward government.
One of the most interesting points to come out of the Democracy Corps study is that moderate Republicans, who make up about 25% of the GOP, feel isolated from their own party. This is mainly because the Tea Party and Evangelicals make up more than 50% of the GOP and have been leading the party into a series of disasters including the recent government shutdown.
The moderates believe in small government but they are not uniformly hostile to Obamacare and they respect science even to the point where some of them have concerns about global warming. They sometimes refer to the conservative wing of the party with such unflattering terms as close-minded, wacky, full of crap, and unelectable.
The moderates prefer politicians who work for compromise and many of them reject Fox News, seeing it as not really a news source at all. According to one moderate respondent, “It tells about as much truth as like Jerry Springer does now.” In sum, the moderate Republicans disagree with Democrats on a number of points, but they don’t seem to be taking any of their cues from an unreal Anti-Cosmos. They are ready to disagree and compromise with Democrats where this will help solve Real World problems.
This entire report is fascinating, at least to us political junkies, but perhaps the most interesting point of all is this: many moderate Republican women look with favor on the possibility of a Hillary Clinton run for the presidency. According to the report, “Weighing the option of voting for Hillary Clinton versus a Republican male, the moderate Republican women in Raleigh chose Clinton, on balance.”
Hillary 2016? How would the Anti-Cosmos deal with that?